i think it would be cool (and would really benefit us newbies) if the more senior people on the forum would evaluate our plans for survival and help us alter and perfect them to guarantee survival in the event of zombie apocalypse! think this would be a cool idea??
We've tried it before and most of the time the person just argues with everyone's suggestion and won't admit any flaws, or choices they make assuming something about a zombie.
Although you could always just post your plan I guess.
I actually think this is a good idea if you have a different goal.
No one ... and let me say it again for emphasis ... NO ONE can come up with the perfect plan, nor can they tell you how to perfect your own plan. Of course, now that I'm done with that bit of semantical masturbation, I will add that we can critique and provide feedback on your plans.
Though I think NIEs structure is a bit rigid, I think the basic idea is good. I think it would be a great idea to have people post their survival ideas (in individual posts, we don't want it all in one) and people can critique their plans.
suuuure!...but there aren't any...
D*** you Nick! This would have been a perfect time to use the island topic. It would have been a perfect example as to why this wouldn't work...
Hahaha. So true, but that topic was a perfect example more-so of how not to post your plan and attempt to fight against criticism.
I wouldn't mind critiquing anyone's plans.
I do however have some rules for posting plans:
The following is my rules for adequate information in posting plans and requested help from me (personally):
I suggest to structure your plans like such:
Plan A
Details of Plan A.
Plan B
Details of Plan B.
Transportation Method
Details of travel method(s).
Escape Rout
Details of Escape Rout.
Party
List of members involved with your survival group and how many stragglers are able to be saved.
Pros & Cons
List of Pros and Cons about all listed above.
Long Term Goals
What are your long-term goals for survival?
Misc.
All miscellaneous information, questions, or comments concerning said Survival Plan.
"The tender fingers of admin are hovering over the ban button; it is our job to keep them there" - Holy Book of Mod
We've tried it before and most of the time the person just argues with everyone's suggestion and won't admit any flaws, or choices they make assuming something about a zombie.
Although you could always just post your plan I guess.
Because The Muppet Show Said So.

Guarantee?? for all you know you could be the start of it. Or you could get bit on your ass while you sleep
Charged - The MC wannabee Ninja
there is no guerintee that any of us will survive it is just assured that we are more likly to survive. and remember there is no safe just safer.
Will you hold me back? If need be I will leave you behind...
I actually think this is a good idea if you have a different goal.
No one ... and let me say it again for emphasis ... NO ONE can come up with the perfect plan, nor can they tell you how to perfect your own plan. Of course, now that I'm done with that bit of semantical masturbation, I will add that we can critique and provide feedback on your plans.
Though I think NIEs structure is a bit rigid, I think the basic idea is good. I think it would be a great idea to have people post their survival ideas (in individual posts, we don't want it all in one) and people can critique their plans.
All that needs to be said is this: FIRE = BAD